Change Country

International Businesses

Proving Beneficial Ownership to China Requires Right Approach

Posted on February 1, 2013 by

Sarah Russell

Sarah Russell

Share This

Foreign investors in China who want to obtain tax treaty benefits for withholding taxes on dividends need to understand the concept of beneficial ownership, communicate it effectively to tax authorities, and compile complete documentation to prove their case. Investors from certain countries that have tax treaties with China may be eligible to have the tax rate on dividend income reduced from 10 percent to 5 percent. However, many companies fail to obtain treaty benefits, because they do not convince tax authorities they are the “beneficial owner” of passive income such as interest, dividends, and royalties. The lower treaty rate is not applicable to US companies with direct investment in China. However may be applicable if the investment in China was structured through a country with the more favorable withholding rate.

Attention on Corporate Income Tax Revenue

China collected RMB 87.17 billion ($14 billion) in corporate income tax revenue from nontax resident enterprises in 2011, and more than half came from withholding tax on dividends. Public Notice No. 30, issued in June by China’s State Administration of Taxation (SAT) , clarified how China would assess beneficial ownership and “affected almost all foreign investors in China.” Notice 30 clarifies an earlier government document, Circular 601, which defines beneficial ownership and lays out seven unfavorable factors that tax authorities consider. To be deemed the “beneficial owner,” companies must show that they have “ownership and control” of the assets and dividends received.

Presenting a Case

Beneficial ownership is complicated, and sometimes tax authorities do not consider all aspects before making a decision. In some cases, tax authorities may “cherry pick one or two factors and ignore the others.” For example, they may apply a very narrow interpretation of the term “business activities,” equating it only with production and trading.

Companies may fail to convince tax authorities that they are entitled to the treaty benefits if they do not adequately review the facts and circumstances of their businesses and formulate technical arguments to help the tax officials understand their case. How the applicant presents the case, demonstrates beneficial ownership status of the company, and the way they approach the tax authority will make a big difference in the treaty application.

Increased Scrutiny

Companies also may run into trouble proving their case, because they cannot produce enough documentation.   Notice 30 lists a number of documents that tax authorities may request in evaluating beneficial ownership status, including articles of association, record of cash flow, minutes of board meetings, and financial statements.

Share This

Sarah Russell

Shareholder

As the leader of the firm's tax group, Sarah supports growth-driven domestic and international businesses with tax planning, consulting and compliance.

Related Insights

International Businesses

Bringing Mobility to Detroit

Posted on September 13, 2022 by

Teresa Gordon leader of the global accounting team at Clayton & McKervey
We’re excited to share this news from the Detroit Regional Partnership. For companies needing help planning mobility focused expansion to the US – from the UK, Europe or Asia, there is a well-connected team to help with all aspects of foreign direct investment.  Learn more about how we can help here.

International Businesses

The Future of Global Mobility Tax

Posted on September 12, 2022 by

Teresa Gordon leader of the global accounting team at Clayton & McKervey
The global mobility landscape is changing. What began as a need to work from home during the worldwide pandemic is evolving into a “work from anywhere” trend that appears to be here to stay. Learn how this impacts the competition for talent and multi-jurisdiction tax compliance.

International Businesses

Teresa Gordon Chosen for SelectUSA Mentorship

Posted on June 24, 2022 by

Clayton & Mckervey
C&M Shareholder Teresa Gordon will be participating in SelectUSA’s Select Global Women in Tech (SGWIT) Mentorship Network.

The Sound of Automation Podcast

Industrial automation businesses are the driving force behind Industry 4.0, and Clayton & McKervey is here to help.

Skip to content