Tax & Assurance Guidance

China Unveils List of 15 Unacceptable Tax Practices in Crackdown on Multinational Companies

Posted on February 5, 2015 by

Clayton & Mckervey

Clayton & McKervey

Share This

Substantial increases in tax disclosures will provide a road map for China’s SAT

China’s State Administration of Taxation (“SAT”) recently announced a major initiative to collect global tax information from multinationals to challenge 15 “unacceptable tax practices.”  The new General Anti-Avoidance Rule (GAAR) Circular No. 32 published on December 12, 2014 signals an accelerated timetable to crackdown on profit shifting through transfer pricing.

Multinational companies of all sizes need to be aware of the SAT’s plans for increased scrutiny, as the SAT has a particular focus on capturing more corporate income tax in China.  To facilitate this initiative, China plans to institute requirements for country-by-country reporting where Chinese and foreign multinationals will need to disclose income taxes paid in every country where they operate to the SAT.

Multinational Tax Matters High on China Leaders’ Agenda

“Efforts should be made to reinforce the international collaboration on tax matters, to crack down on cross-border tax avoidance and evasion.”

– China President Xi Jinping at the 9th G20 Leaders’ Summit, November 2014

According to the SAT, President Xi’s comments were the first time tax matters have been included in a high-profile international speech by a Chinese president. China’s SAT has responded by issuing a detailed set of coordinated guidelines for challenging tax avoidance arrangements.

What Issues Are Under Scrutiny?

The GAAR Circular finalizes certain procedural guidelines for taxpayers and enforcement priorities for tax authorities.  Specifically, the Circular aims to contest transactions (a) where the main benefit is to realize a tax benefit or (b) do not have economic substance.

China’s 15 ‘Unacceptable Tax Practices’

  1. Base erosion and profit shifting
  2. Failure to respect specific qualities of Chinese market (expectations for higher profits based upon access to Chinese customers)
  3. Aggressive tax planning
  4. Low return of high-technology enterprises (companies benefitting from the preferential high technology tax rate are expected to earn higher profits)
  5. Hybrids for tax avoidance
  6. Unreasonable expense deductions (e.g., excessive service charges)
  7. Return unmatched with the functions and value contributions (lower than expected profits for functions performed in China)
  8. Abusive use of tax treaties
  9. Arrangements without substantive economic activities
  10. Non-cooperation in submitting documentation
  11. Foreign losses shifted to China (e.g., Chinese subsidiaries that regularly incur losses)
  12. Double or multiple non-taxation
  13. Losses incurred by single-function enterprises (distributors or contact manufacturers)
  14. Non-transparent tax system
  15. Unreasonably high pricing of intangibles (royalties)

What Can Companies Do?

For many multinationals, many of the 15 Unacceptable Tax Practices relate to profit margins earned by Chinese subsidiaries of foreign-parent companies.  The SAT is convinced that multinationals are utilizing the intercompany prices of goods, services, royalties and other transactions to undercompensate their Chinese affiliates.

In our experience, many multinationals rely on a transfer pricing policy without necessarily revisiting the end results for reasonableness.   Other companies rely on outdated transfer pricing reports or analyses.  In both cases, the SAT is now better positioned to challenge the standard way of doing things.

Since Chinese tax authorities will have new tools to audit companies, now is an ideal time to revisit a company’s transfer pricing approach from both a Chinese and overseas tax authority perspective.  Bottom line, China is introducing more aggressive tax audit processes to claim a greater share from companies with operations in China.

Clayton & McKervey

Related Insights

Digital Advisory Services

Using Standardization for Anything-But-Standard Results

Posted on June 29, 2022 by

Elly Mioduszewski
Running your business is hard, but how it’s run can be made easier. Implementing standardized work processes can provide you and your team with more time to look at results so you can determine where to go next—rather than spending unnecessary time capturing and correcting routine activity. 

Tax & Assurance Guidance

Understanding Your Cash Flow is Important-Here’s Why

Posted on June 24, 2022 by

Dave Van Damme
Managing cash flow in a business should go far beyond ensuring that you have funds available to pay your current bills. While that’s a threshold every new business should meet, developing deeper cash flow management skills is necessary to scale your business and prevent unnecessary stress. 

International Businesses

Teresa Gordon Selected for Select USA Mentorship Program 

Posted on June 24, 2022 by

Clayton & Mckervey
C&M Shareholder Teresa Gordon will be participating in SelectUSA’s Select Global Women in Tech (SGWIT) Mentorship Network.

Sign up for our newsletters

Get business and industry-specific news and knowledge straight from our consultants and accounting specialists.

The Sound of Automation Podcast

The Sound of Automation Podcast

Industrial automation businesses are the driving force behind Industry 4.0, and Clayton & McKervey is here to help.

Insights & Perspectives

Using Standardization for Anything-But-Standard Results

Running your business is hard, but how it’s run can be made easier. Implementing standardized work processes can provide you and your team with more time to look at results so you can determine where to go next—rather than spending unnecessary time capturing and correcting routine activity. 

Read More

The Sound of Automation Podcast

Industrial automation businesses are the driving force behind Industry 4.0, and Clayton & McKervey is here to help.

Skip to content